Preacutionary labelling of cross-reactive foods: The case of rapeseed

Asthma Research and Practice

Alessandro Fiocchi, Lamia Dahdah, Carla Riccardi, Oscar Mazzina and Vincenzo Fierro

Abstract

Food allergic individuals are exposed to unnecessary dietary restrictions due to precautionary food allergy labelling (PFAL). Two forms of PFAL exist: type I identifies the possible presence of allergenic contaminaion in foods (‘may content…’), type II indicates as potentially dangerous ingredients or contaminants that do no belong to official list of food allergens. PFAL type II is based on the fear of cross-reactivity with foods belonging to that list. PFAL type II is less known, but may be tempting for the legal offices of food companies, for clinicians in a ‘defensive medicine’ key, and even for legislators. We identify here a case of PFAL type II, allergy to rapeseed (belonging to the family of Brassicaceae). Increasingly used for their nutritional and nutraceutic value in asthma prevention, rapeseed has been indicated by regulatory authorities in Canada and Europe as potential cross-reactor with mustard. In this review, we provide the elements for a risk assessment of cross-reactivity of rapeseed/mustard allergy in the general population both clinically and from the point of view of the molecular allergy. Three findings emerge:

1. Allergic reactions to rapeseed are exceptional

2. The allergens identified in rapeseed and mustard are similar, but not identical

3. Reactions to rapeseed have never been described in mustard-allergic patients.

On the ground of existing evidence, a precautionary labeling for rapeseed as potentially dangerous for patients allergic to mustard is not justified. In the interest of patients with multiple food allergy, PFAL type II must be avoided.

Download PDF

 

(You must be logged in to add and reply comments)

Interasma on Twitter

Interasma Top story: EAACI on Twitter: "A new strategy to prevent development of #foodallhttps://t.co/1Bk3fmuDx1, see more https://t.co/CpGiFuOOYd
2hreplyretweetfavorite
Interasma RT @EAACI_HQ: A new strategy to prevent development of #foodallergy in Icelandic children: consuming fish oil during infancy! #Allergy_jour
6hreplyretweetfavorite
Interasma RT @Dr_Mingma: @worldallergy Wonderful talk by Dr Neil Barnes on Salford Lung Study Asthma - consideration from latest evidence. @GSK @worl
6hreplyretweetfavorite
Interasma RT @Dr_Mingma: Wonderful talk by Dr Neil Barnes on Salford Lung Study Asthma - consideration from latest evidence. @GSK @worldallergy Annua…
6hreplyretweetfavorite

Editor: Juan C. Ivancevich, MD

Copyright © Interasma 2003-2017  •  Terms of Use  •  Privacy Policy  •  Contact Us  •  Sitemap

Powered by FREI SA

InterAsma